Disparities in Marriage Dispensation Due to Pregnancy: Analysis of Vage Women Norm and Maṣlaḥah Mursalah

Jumrotunisak Jumrotunisak; Khairil Anwar; Mowafg Abrahem Masuwd

doi:10.58421/misro.v5i1.1235

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.58421/misro.v5i1.1235

Authors

Jumrotunisak Jumrotunisak Universitas Islam Negeri Palangka Raya
Khairil Anwar Universitas Islam Negeri Palangka Raya
Mowafg Abrahem Masuwd University of Zawia

Keywords:

Child protection, Judicial discretion, Marriage dispensation, Pregnancy outside marriage, Religious court, Thematic coding

Abstract

This study examines the disparity in marriage dispensation decisions in cases of pregnancy outside marriage at the Pangkalan Bun Religious Court. The research examines the ambiguity of the phrase “very urgent reasons” in Indonesian marriage law, which affords broad judicial discretion and may lead to inconsistent decisions. The objective of this study is to analyze how judges interpret and apply this provision in deciding marriage dispensation cases involving pregnancy. This research employs a qualitative normative approach by analyzing 32 court decisions issued by the Pangkalan Bun Religious Court, complemented by interviews with judges. The data were analyzed using thematic coding to identify recurring patterns in judicial reasoning. The findings reveal two dominant orientations in judicial considerations. The first orientation emphasizes protecting the unborn child's lineage and legal status, which often leads to approval of dispensation requests. The second orientation focuses on long-term child protection, considering factors such as psychological maturity, economic readiness, and the sustainability of future family life, resulting in the rejection of some petitions despite pregnancy. The disparity in decisions reflects the open-ended nature of the legal norm and demonstrates the dynamics of judicial ijtihad in balancing legal certainty and public interest. This study recommends the development of clearer interpretative parameters to promote consistency while ensuring stronger child protection in marriage dispensation practices.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

I. Ghazali and A. Z. M. Hammad, Al Mustasfa Min Ilm Al Usul - Imam Ghazali. Repro Books Limited, 2017.

W. Az-Zuhaili, Al-Fiqh al-Islami wa Adillatuhu. Darul Fikri, 1998.

M. Miswanto, “Relevansi maṣlaḥah mursalah dalam pembaruan hukum keluarga Islam di Indonesia.,” Maz. J. Pemikir. Huk. Islam, vol. 18, no. 2, pp. 201–220, 2019.

A. Farih, “REINTERPRETASI MAṢLAḤAH SEBAGAI METODE ISTINBĀṬ HUKUM ISLAM: Studi Pemikiran Hukum Islam Abū Isḥāq Ibrāhīm al-Shāṭibī,” Al-Ahkam, vol. 25, no. April, pp. 43–66, 2015.

W. B. Hallaq, An introduction to Islamic law. Cambridge University Press, 2009.

L. Adyani, I. Rahmawati, and D. Suryana, “Dampak perkawinan usia anak terhadap ketahanan keluarga dan kesehatan reproduksi: Studi empiris di Indonesia.,” J. Kesehat. Reproduksi, vol. 14, no. 1, pp. 45–60, 2023.

L. Romdiyani, “Variasi pertimbangan hakim dalam perkara dispensasi kawin akibat hamil di luar nikah. , 20(2), 255–274.,” Al-‘Adalah J. Huk. Islam, vol. 20, no. 2, pp. 255–274., 2023.

S. Rahardjo, Ilmu Hukum Bandung. Bandung: Citra Aditya Bakti, 2014.

A. Ramdani, “Disparitas putusan dispensasi kawin dan problem kepastian hukum di pengadilan agama,” J. Huk. dan Peradil., vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 361–377, 2021.

N. Hidayati, “Dampak perkawinan usia dini terhadap ketahanan keluarga di Indonesia. , 14(2), 157–176.,” J. Sosiol. Agama, vol. 14., no. 2, pp. 157–176., 2020.

A. M. Widodo and N. W. R. Mumpuni, “Implementasi Dispensasi Kawin Pasca Perubahan Undang-Undang Perkawinan (Studi Permohonan Dispensasi Kawin Di Pengadilan Agama Klaten),” Al Maqashidi J. Huk. Islam Nusant., vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 220–235, 2025.

L. Munawaroh, N. Musyarafak, and R. Raharjo, “Dispensasi Perkawinan dan Implikasinya terhadap Ketahanan Keluarga,” J. Legis. Indones., vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 267–279, 2024.

S. Mertokusumo, “Penemuan hukum sebuah pengantar,” 1997.

A. Ali, Menguak Teori Hukum & Teori Peradilan: Legal Theory & Judicialprudence. Jakarta: Kencana, 2013.

J. Efendi and J. Ibrahim, Metode Penelitian Hukum: Normatif dan Empiris. Prenada Media, 2018.

M. B. Kurniawan and D. Refiasari, “Penafsiran makna ‘alasan sangat mendesak’ dalam penolakan permohonan dispensasi kawin,” J. Yudisial, vol. 15, no. 1, pp. 83–98, 2022.

UNICEF, “Child marriage: Latest trends and future prospects.,” 2021. [Online]. Available: https://data.unicef.org/topic/child-protection/child-marriage/.

S. Butt, T. Lindsey, and H. Pausacker, “Judges and the dilemma of child marriage dispensation in Indonesia.,” Int. J. Law, Policy Fam., vol. 37, no. 1, 2023.

S. Achten and C. Lessmann, “Spatial inequality, geography and economic activity,” World Dev., vol. 136, p. 105114, 2020.

A. Daly, “The best interests of the child principle in family law decision-making: A socio-legal analysis,” Int. J. Law, Policy Fam., vol. 34, no. 3, pp. 289–313, Dec. 2020.

J. Tobin, “The indeterminacy of the best interests principle and the limits of child rights adjudication.,” Int. J. Child. Rights, vol. 30, no. 3, pp. 507–526., 2022.

K. Von Benda-beckmann and B. Turner, “Legal pluralism , social theory , and the state,” J. Leg. Plur. Unoff. Law, vol. 50, no. 3, pp. 255–274, 2019.

J. W. Creswell and C. N. Poth, Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches. (4th ed.). Sage., 2018.

H. L. A. Hart, The concept of law. Oxford University Press., 1961.

V. Braun and V. Clarke, “Using thematic analysis in psychology,” Qual. Res. Psychol., vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 77–101., 2006.

R. M. Cover, Nomos and narrative. Harvard University Press, 1982.

R. B. Hunter, The Changes That Took Place in the Judicial System. Oxford University Press, 2004.

M. Q. Patton, Qualitative research & evaluation methods. SAGE Publications., 2015.

F. Rahman, Islam & modernity: Transformation of an intellectual tradition, vol. 15. University of Chicago Press, 2017.

R. Dworkin, Taking rights seriously. A&C Black, 2013.

L. L. Fuller, The morality of law. Yale University Press., 1969.

H. Kliemt, “The nature and significance of the political ideal of the Rule of Law: Hayek, Buchanan, and beyond,” Kyklos, vol. 77, no. 4, pp. 1084–1102, 2024.

K. Nisa, Sukiati, and M. Y. Harahap, “Yurisprudensi Hukum Dispensasi Pernikahan Melalui Penetapan Pengadilan ( Studi Putusan Nomor 105 / Pdt . P / 2024 / PA . Buol ),” Innov. J. Soc. Sci. Res., vol. 5, no. 4, pp. 56–71, 2025.

S. G. D. Q. Campos and B. J. Américo, “Integrity at Sentencing and the Issue of Judicial Discretion from a Dworkinian Perspective,” Beijing Law Rev., vol. 14, no. 2, pp. 828–853, 2023.

H. G. Gadamer, Truth and method. Continuum: London, 1975.

R. Banakar and M. Travers, Theory and method in socio-legal research. Bloomsbury Publishing, 2005.

A. Purwanti and A. Natalis, “Law as Text, Culture as Context: The Semiotics of Marriage Dispensation and Judicial Considerations in Indonesia,” Int. J. Semiot. Law - Rev. Int. Sémiotique Jurid., vol. 39, no. 2, pp. 729–760, 2026.

J. Auda, Maqasid al-Shariah as philosophy of Islamic law: A systems approach. International Institute of Islamic Thought (IIIT), 2008.

N. M. Nour, “Health Consequences of Child Marriage in Africa,” Emerg. Infect. Dis., vol. 12, no. 11, pp. 1644–1649, 2006.

A. Raj, N. Saggurti, D. Balaiah, and J. G. Silverman, “Prevalence of child marriage and its effect on fertility and fertility-control outcomes of young women in India: a cross-sectional, observational study.,” Lancet (London, England), vol. 373, no. 9678, pp. 1883–1889, May 2009.

A. U. Sezgin and R.-L. Punamäki, “Impacts of early marriage and adolescent pregnancy on mental and somatic health: the role of partner violence,” Arch. Womens. Ment. Health, vol. 23, no. 2, pp. 155–166, 2020.

A. J. Melnikas, N. Mulauzi, J. Mkandawire, and S. Amin, “Perceptions of minimum age at marriage laws and their enforcement : qualitative evidence from Malawi,” BMC Public Health, vol. 21, no. 1, p. 1350, 2021.

K. Anwar, A. Saefulloh, S. Surawan, S. Nalus and Z. Zuzanti, “Dayak Ngaju Customary Sanctions as a Rehabilitation Mechanism for Drug Addicts in Central Kalimantan”, El-Mashlahah, vol. 15, no. 1, pp. 165–188, Jun. 2025.

S. Surawan, A. Ariyadi, M. R. Anshari, and M. T. Ramadhani, "Pembinaan Remaja Dalam Rangka Mencegah Pernikahan Dini di SMA Muhammadiyah Palangka Raya." Jurnal Penamas Adi Buana, vol. 7, no. 02, pp. 121-129, 2024.